Politics & Society
July Thu 01, 2010
<< Prima Pagina
6. From this premise the conclusion is inevitable: Having a crucifix on the walls of classrooms was obviously found as expressing an assessment of the legitimacy of religious conviction – Christianity – and hence violative.
7. This formulation of “neutrality” is based on two conceptual errors which are fatal to the conclusions.
8. First, under the Convention system all Members must, indeed, guarantee individuals freedom of religion but also freedom from religion. This obligation represents a common constitutional asset of Europe. It is, however, counter balanced by considerable liberty when it comes to the place of religion or religious heritage in the collective identity of the nation and the symbology of the State.
9. Thus, there are Members in which laïcité is part of the very definition of the State, such as France and in which, indeed, there can be no State endorsed or sponsored religious symbol in a public space. Religion is a private affair.
10. But no State is not required under the Convention system to espouse laïcité. Thus, just across the Channel there is England (and I use this term advisedly) in which there is an Established State Church, in which the Head of State is also the Head of the Church, in which religious leaders, are members, ex ufficio, of the legislative branch, in which the flag carries the Cross and in which the National Anthem is a prayer to God to save the Monarch, and give him or her Victory and Glory. [Sometimes God does not listen as in a certain football match a few days some days ago…]
11. In its very self definition as a State with such an established Church, in its very ontology, England would appear to violate the strictures of the Chamber for how could it be said that with all those symbols there is not some kind of assessment of the legitimacy of religious belief?
12. There is a huge diversity of State-Church arrangement in Europe. More than half the population of Europe lives in States which could not be described as laïque. Inevitably in public education, the State and its symbols have a place. Many of these, however, have a religious origin or contemporary religious identity. In Europe, the Cross is the most visible example appearing as it does on endless flags, crests, buildings etc. It is wrong to argue, as some have, that it is o n l y or m e r e l y a national symbol. But it is equally wrong to argue, as some have, that it has only religious significance. It is both – Given history that is part of the national identity of many European States. [There are scholars who claim that the 12 Stars of the Council of Europe has this very duality too!]
USE BUTTONS BELOW TO KEEP READING ON NEXT PAGE
Incidenti: auto contro moto in via Ostiense, centauro muore a Roma
Viabilita': statale 36 resta chiusa tra Bellano e Lecco per frana
Berlusconi: Servizi sociali, prossima settimana si decide progetto
M.O.: fonti mediche, 2 palestinesi feriti in raid aereo israeliano su Gaza
Egitto: proteste ad al-Azhar, studenti e docenti condannati a 3 anni di carcere
Staminali: Belleri su inchiesta Stamina, valuteremo come muoverci
Read all News